You don’t have to know me well – in fact, you barely have to know me at all – to know that I am not a reactionary person. I generally contemplate more than complain, and am not one to get bent out of shape over minor scandals or trendy causes. So I hope you will appreciate the extent of consideration and concern I have put into the following, and understand that when I say this is probably the most important thing I have ever asked of you, I really, really mean it.
Awful, terrible, scary things happened in Toronto this weekend. Yet even scarier than the violence and mayhem in the streets are some of the arguments I hear from otherwise reasonable people in defense of the atrocious abuse of charter rights perpetrated by G20 security forces and supported by all levels of government.
Discussions with those presenting these arguments have shown me that many are simply unaware of what happened this weekend. Perhaps you decided to get out of town for the duration of the summit (a prudent move, no argument) and since returning all you’ve heard of what happened is a few snippets from the TV or the radio about violence and riots. My intention was to put together a primer on the events of this weekend, referencing various news sources, but instead all I’m going to say is this: if you read nothing else about what happened at the G20 this weekend, if you do no more research beyond this sentence, then please first read this account of the inexplicable arrest and detainment of a pretty average citizen. It’s a long read, for sure, but it provides a detailed, captivating account of what happened to one Torontonian that is undeniable, compelling, and at times even funny. If you’re still skeptical, a little bit of research will corroborate many of the writer’s claims of police disorganization, contempt, abuse, homophobia, and lies.
To those of you who live far from the downtown core of Toronto and had the luxury of staying away: imagine if a crime occurred in your neighbourhood and the police responded by quickly surrounding the area and everyone in it (including you), arresting them, and then releasing people hours later after deciding that they weren’t the perpetrators of the crime. You’d be pissed, and rightfully so – the police have no right to arrest hundreds of people just because a few of them may be guilty. Now consider that this is not an analogy for what happened this weekend – this IS what happened.
Why would the police do such a thing, you ask? What would they have to gain? The Star has a pretty good idea in this article on the Miami Model.
Meanwhile, actual perpetrators of violence got of scott free. Police did not try to apprehend ‘black bloc’ tacticians, allowing windows to be smashed and cars to be burned for hours. When I headed down to Spadina and Queen on Saturday I watched a police car – already surrounded by hundreds of police – burn for a good 45 minutes (and it had been burning since long before I arrived) before the police bothered to move in and extinguish it. And when a few bad apples tried to disrupt an otherwise innocuous gathering, the crowd reacted. At one point a man pointed out a guy who had thrown something into the crowd. “This guy!,” he said, “in the white shirt!”, and at least fifty civilians (no exaggeration – it was hilarious. All that was missing was Yakety Sax.) chased the perpetrator down an alley. Not a single police officer (though there were many to spare) supported the pursuit, and the man got away.
If you haven’t already seen this video of a civilian totally pwning a would-be looter, treat yourself – it’s very satisfying. But it raises the question: why were civilians left to enforce order, and not the $1 billion worth of security forces? Naomi Klein has a pretty good idea in this video.
Instead, police used a tactic known as “kettling” to detain hundreds of innocent people for hours – even though both police and the mayor’s office admit that only a handful of people were responsible for the violence (which, incidentally, had taken place a day before). Police even apprehended journalists. If you haven’t already read Steve Paikin’s chilling account of the beating and arrest of a journalist on Saturday night, please do. And please, please – if you can’t understand how atrocious it is for the police to arrest journalists who are merely trying to document public events, ask a grown up to explain it to you. I don’t have the patience to draw you a picture.
Since the G20 has ended, Police Chief Bill Blair has admitted to deliberatlely misleading the people of Toronto regarding the secret laws that were passed for the summit. He has also admitted to stocking a press conference that was supposed to showcase confiscated protestor weapons with items that in fact had nothing to do with the G20 at all, and weren’t even weapons. On Tuesday evening a group of people (including myself) showed up to protest Bill Blair’s appearance at at Pride Toronto event. When asked if he knew why the group outside was so upset, Blair replied “I don’t know, and I’m not sure I care“. This is the man who now thinks the only review of police conduct at the G20 summit should be an internal one, despite his flagrant failure to uphold the Toronto Police Services values of honesty and openness.
I’m not one to throw around ‘isms, but the events of this weekend and the subsequent attitude of Bill Blair smack of authoritarianism. I firmly believe that this is a watershed moment in Canadian history: either we stand up and demand accountability and redress for the events of this weekend, or we do nothing – sending the message to the government and the police that whatever they say, goes, regardless of whatever rights we think we have.
So please – PLEASE – do something. Write to the mayor (mayor_miller@toronto.ca), your city councillor, your MP, your MPP, and the Prime Minister’s office (you can also quickly send a pre-written email to the PM’s office from Amnesty International’s website) demanding an inquiry into G20 security measures, and the removal of Bill Blair from his position as Chief of Police. And then write to them again. One little email is meaningless, but thousands of them can’t be ignored.
Please join me this evening at the Rally for a Public Inquiry Concerning the Actions at the G20. And while you’re at it, join the Facebook group (it’ll keep you informed) and sign the petition.
If you’re not quite convinced yet, here are a few more links you should check out:
Torontoist’s Fourteen Essential G20 Videos
http://backofthebook.ca/2010/06/27/widespread-police-misbehaviour-illegal-activity-at-g20/3402/
http://spacingtoronto.ca/2010/06/28/g20-a-few-questions-to-ask-organizers-of-g20/
http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorials/article/829515–call-inquiry-on-g20-mayhem
http://toronto.mediacoop.ca/video/compilation-videos-about-police-violence/3897
http://www.amnesty.ca/resource_centre/news/view.php?load=arcview&article=5453&c=Resource+Centre+News